The moral issues of cloning

Recall the story of Noah's unmarried daughters who tried to get their father drunk so that they might have children by him. Anticipating that one day the cloning of a human being might be attempted, Donum Vitae said this: A Christian understanding of human nature must take due account not only of human finitude but also of human fallenness.

Because I did not harm her, I did not do anything morally wrong in this circumstance. Wadsworth Publishing Company, pp. Some of the more extravagant claims for the potential of genetics see the human genome project as a further step along the road of human autonomy and mastery over nature.

These factors will contribute to viewing and treating the child as a mere commodity. Most supporters also argue that the embryo demands special moral consideration, requiring regulation and oversight by funding agencies.

In British developmental biologist Ian Wilmut generated a cloned sheep, named Dollyby means of nuclear transfer involving an enucleated embryo and a differentiated cell nucleus.

The tissue could be experimented upon to understand why disease occurs. Since the focus is primarily on the issues themselves, the approach taken is to address the underlying ethical aspects in respect of particular issues as they arise. The dangers of natural reproduction. As abovementioned, there is much evidence to suggest that genetic determinism is not true.

In a team of scientists cloned a rhesus monkey through a process called embryonic cell nuclear transferwhich is similar to SCNT except that it uses DNA from an undifferentiated embryo. Finally, even if safety concerns are sufficient to warrant a current ban on human reproductive cloning, such concerns would be temporary, and would abate as cloning becomes safer.

Yet we are more than dust - we have the breath of life. Therefore, I have usually done nothing morally wrong by deliberately bringing into existence a child who suffers from mental, physical, or developmental impairments.

Of more concern is the generation of false optimism on the part of anyone involved - scientists, medical staff, health authorities, Government, and especially any commercial biotechnology firms who market the drugs, diagnostics kits or other supplies. Key concepts within which to frame a biblical view in this area are the nature of human being, and the constraints on what is permissible in the context of relationship.

If a patient were to receive stem cell therapy in order to treat some affliction, her body may reject the stem cells for the same reason human bodies have a tendency to reject donated organs: Cloning would provide such an opportunity to grieving parents.

The same can be said about cloning Pence, and ; Wachbroit, This would be a new and terrible form of slavery. The prospect of creating a child, solely to meet the needs of another child and not for her own sake, reduces the created child to a mere means to achieve the ends of the parents and the sick child.

This has become a favourite topic for speculation and a source of catchy headlines in the media, but without any regard for the impracticability of the idea, thus perpetuating misconceptions and raising false alarms.

The studies conducted by Golombok certainly seem to provide evidence to the contrary. In presidential systems, the executive acts as both head of state and head of government, and has power to appoint an unelected cabinet.

Therefore, a child born with mental, physical or developmental impairments is not made worse off by being brought into existence. The Dickey-Wicker amendmentattached to U. The Church needs to continue to make its voice heard in relation to these issues, and we should also pray regularly for those on ethical committees who make decisons on difficult issues under considerable pressures.

Finally, each individual member can play a role in discussing these issues from the point of view of the love of God and of our neighbour.

Applied Ethics

It is unethical to experiment on an embryo for the same reason it is unethical to experiment on any human being and since embryo experimentation often results in the destruction of the embryo, this equates to murdering the embryo Deckers, ; Oduncu, ; Novak, Is there a difference.

That is, while we ought not to prevent anyone from procreating, we are not required to provide them with any technology whatsoever in order to enable them to procreate if they cannot do so by their own means.

Selected Quotes from Church Documents: On Human Cloning

Without questioning the motives of those using these techniques, Donum Vitae pointed out that people can do harm to themselves and others even as they try to do what is good, that is, overcome infertility.

This is the direction that research must follow if it wishes to respect the dignity of each and every human being, even at the embryonic stage.

Ministers or other officials head a country's public offices, such as a foreign ministry or defence ministry. The more complex and powerful the technology, like genetics engineering, the more important this is. They may not be entitled to the use of a certain technological advancement e.

Such confusion would not warrant a prohibition on cloning. Applied Ethics. Under what conditions is an abortion morally permissible? Does a citizen have a moral obligation to actively participate (perhaps by voting) in the democratic process of one’s nation (assuming one is living in a democracy)?

Cloning: Cloning, the process of generating a genetically identical copy of a cell or an organism. Cloning happens often in nature, as when a cell replicates itself asexually without genetic alteration or recombination. Learn more about cloning experiments, cloning techniques, and the ethics of human reproductive cloning.

In bioethics, the ethics of cloning refers to a variety of ethical positions regarding the practice and possibilities of cloning, especially human many of these views are religious in origin, some of the questions raised by cloning are faced by secular perspectives as well.

Perspectives on human cloning are theoretical, as human therapeutic and reproductive cloning are not. Conservative position: "Cloning, even so-called therapeutic or experimental cloning, creates a new life without a father, and reduces a mother to the provider of an almost emptied schmidt-grafikdesign.comeless, it is a new human life and the determination to destroy it and limit its use to scientific research for therapeutic ends compound further the moral issues rather than protect mankind.

The Legal and Ethical Issues of Cloning That Make it Controversial. ~ These and other such issues present an ethical and moral dilemma for scientists and experts alike who see cloning as a potential danger to human identity.

The Ethical Issues - In Detail. Religious Belief and Control. Cloning is rapidly emerging as one of the most controversial and emotion-laden of topics in todays world. To clone or not to clone: that is.

The moral issues of cloning
Rated 3/5 based on 19 review
BBC - Ethics: Abortion